Alayk As-Salaam
Wow, now that's what I am talking about. A real discourse. I am glad I am not the only one fond of writing essays? Are you sure you don't want to be a teacher?!
I have noted your points and I think I agree with you on many of those points and arguments. However, there are maybe areas of what I call alternative interpretations. If you take Hausa music as a cultural expression, then that fits in with your idea of what constitutes Hausa music. However, there is a point that needs to be further clarified, and that is whether Hausa musicians are being artistic for entertainment purposes (as your Fulbe friend in Sakkwato), or whether they are merely motivated by "roko".
For instance, Dan Anace is possibly one of the greatest Hausa musicians EVER. His classic ADO DAN KORE is absolutely fantastic. Yet within his lyrics he made it clear that he was a "maroki". Similarly, Shata was another classical Hausa singer. Yet a vast percentage of his catalog is "roko" themed songs. There are, of course, many that were pure entertainment such as KUMBO AFOLLO 11, or MATA KUYI AURE.
Other musicians, as you pointed out, focused their attention on court and emirate epics, detailing the glories of past rulers and kings. Some, particularly what can be called "younger generation" may not identify with these epics. Yet still other musicians, are of the "bara" variety - street singers who move from cluster of people to cluster singing and getting few pennies thrown their way. Muhammad Dahiru Daura (go to the audio section of
www.dandalic.com for a sampler) belongs to this category. And hard as it may seem, Barmani Choge's "crap" is adored by many people, and classificationally, she is in the same category as Shata or Dan Anace in the sense that they are all "maroka" and people oriented in their songs. Barmani, like others, had also branched out into the pure entertainment field, by releasing songs like AKAMA SANA'A MATA, WAKAR DA'A, and WAKAR KISHIYA (which she borrowed from Uwaliya Mai Amada).
But you have pointed out a very vital weakness in Hausa music - instrumentation. Hausa music, in my view, is not "music oriented" as such, it is more of a vocal-oriented thing. There is no instrumental vitrosity. The genius of the musician lies not so much in his play of instrumentation, but in his lyrics. Listen to Dan Anace when he says:
"Ni ko na sani Duniya makaranta ce
Na kuma na sani Duniya makabarta ce..."
(from ADO DAN KORE)
Yet the instrumentation remains monotonous throughout ALL his songs - just like Shata's songs. Again compare the opening bars of Shata's classic BAKANDAMIYA. Indeed in an interview, Shata himself said he wanted to be remembered with this song. It is pure Hausa brilliance. Yet beside the deafening drumming at the beginning, the rest of the beat settled down to fixed montony.
Now compare these with Danmarya Jos. That is the nearest equivalent of Jimi Hendrix we have! There is a lot of variation in his instrumentation - depending on the song. This style was also used by Garba Sufa, Hassan Wayam, Garba Leo, and Amadun Doka.
But do you notice what connects these last lot? They were singer-players! That is they not only control the tempo, beat and pattern of the music by playing the leading instruments, but they are the lead vocalists - so they give the music its direction. Shata, Barmani, Dan Anace, Dan Dawo, Dankwairo and others are lead vocalists ONLY, and do not play any instrument. For that reason, their music tended to be less melodious than others (or because they are kalangu musicians, whereas others use stringed instruments).
And how do we categorize those musicians who do not use any instrument? Again Muhammad Dahiru Daura, the blind begger-musician who is ignored by many researchers including Prof. Graham Furniss, belongs to this category. Instead of an instrument, his vocalists use their voice in a distored form to lay down a background matrix on which the lead vocalist builds his operatic-style drama.Also when Garba Gashuwa released SANNU DA HIMMA SHUGABAN KASA, BABANGIDA MAI SON GYARA KASATA, it was without any instrumentation. It was later when the song became a hit that he employed three girls to provide chorus, and a kalangu player to join. I prefered the non-musical version!
The issue of boys and girls dancing, of course, does not arise in a traditional Muslim society such as the Hausa society. That does not mean they don't do it; but certainly no Hausa musician would seem to be encouraging that. However, the classic kalangu players who used to play in clubs (and shown on Radio Television Kaduna's KADE-KADENMU) usually had a combination of boys and girls dancing in a choreographic set. But the typical impression of such dancers among many people was that they were "yan iska"! At ceremonies, boys dance separately in a very energetic end of the day dance routine called, Kombo (if I recall), while girls dance earlier before this thrasing about by boys charged with lots of hormones!
So what are the areas of transformation of Hausa music?
1. I agree with the need to revist the instrumentation. But Dan Sakkawato, most of our musicians cannot play modern instruments, and they just would not be bothered to learn them. Like you, I detest these Casio-manufactured sounds used in creating the song soundtracks for Hausa home videos; but this is all they have at the moment.
2. The vocals. We need to start focusing on issues, not praise singing. Hausa music is predicated on PRAISE SINGING. There is no running away from that. However a brilliant move along opposite direction is by a young Kano musician called Sadi Sidi who mimics the voice of one of the more popular Hausa home video actors, Dan Ibro (Rabilu Musa). Sadi's parody of some well known musicians (especially Awilo and Shata) is fantastic because he takes their theme and beat, and CHANGES their lyrics to something more positive. I wish it were possible to make attachments to these postings, otherwise, I would have attached small MP3 clips of examples.
3. Dancing? Well, do whatever take your fancy! Why not? It is the issue of mixed gender dancing that will need to be religiously and culturally negotiated; and I don't think it can be allowed. That was the stand of the Kano State Censorship Board on this issue when they banned mixed gender dancing in films produced in Kano.
I am posting this, and soon will start a thread on HAUSA POETS.
Salaam all
Abdalla